Grilling a design before we build it
The most expensive thing in this project is a vague specification. A design that was agreed too easily gets built, and then changed once someone sees it working. So every design is grilled before a line of code is written.
The grill. A grill is an interactive session. The design’s author answers hard questions, one at a time, and the design is corrected as the answers land. It is only as good as its questions. A tired author asks easy ones.
The workflow. Since 31 July 2026 a workflow prepares the questions first. It runs several AI reviewers in parallel, in four stages:
-
Digest. One reader turns the design into claims under test: its decisions, what it touches, what it leaves out.
-
Interrogate. Two readers attack it. The first sits in four seats in turn:
- the clerk, mid-task and under time pressure;
- the auditor, reconstructing what happened months later;
- the financial director, accountable for the numbers;
- the salesperson, in a demo against an incumbent vendor.
The second reads the seams: what happens to existing records, which settings need a default, what crosses into another module. Every question must cite the file it was grounded in.
-
Verify. A separate reader tries to refute each question. If the design or the code already answers it, the question dies here.
-
Agenda. The survivors are merged and ranked by how expensive a wrong answer would be. A wrong screen is cheap. A wrong event is not.
What the author sees. A short agenda, most expensive first. The author then grills with it, in person. The workflow never answers its own questions and never edits the design. Judgement stays human.
Tests written blind. A second step follows the grill. A separate agent reads the design’s scenarios and writes the acceptance tests before any code exists. It has never seen the implementation. The failing test is the acceptance criterion, and a step cannot be committed while it is red.
Why it matters. Questions that used to surface in user testing now surface in the design. The salesperson’s seat is the one most often missing from a design review. Here it is always in the room. The whole loop, from decision record to land, is on How we build.
Written by Jeremy Rich.